Page 1 of 2

Guided Casper - Bedside Manner

Context:
A new doctor, Shaun, is part of a team discussing a patient's case, who's presenting with abdominal pain, and the team suspects a malignant sarcoma. The patient overhears the discussion and becomes frightened. Shaun doesn't sugarcoat the situation and bluntly tells the patient the gravity of the situation. This sparks a disagreement among the team members about how patient information should be delivered.

Question: As a future doctor, how would you balance the ethical responsibility of being truthful to a patient with delivering information in a compassionate manner, especially when the prognosis is severe?

Question: As a future doctor, how would you balance the ethical responsibility of being truthful to a patient with delivering information in a compassionate manner, especially when the prognosis is severe?

In such a difficult situation, it's important to be both honest and compassionate. I would tell the patient the truth, but in a way that's considerate of their feelings. It's a balancing act between not withholding critical information and not causing unnecessary distress. I would also offer support and discuss the next steps.

As a doctor, my main responsibility is to the patient and their health. I would be upfront about the situation, giving them the necessary facts. I understand that this news could be devastating, but I believe in honesty. However, I could use some guidance on how to deliver such news more gently.

As a physician, I believe in the importance of truth and compassion in patient care. I would take the time to gently and respectfully explain the diagnosis to the patient. I would ensure that the patient is comfortable, understands the prognosis, and is aware of the potential treatment options. I would emphasize that we are a team in this journey and that we will do everything we can to support them during this challenging time. This approach demonstrates empathy, professionalism, and respect for the patient's autonomy.

Guided Casper - Bedside Manner

Question: As a future doctor, how would you balance the ethical responsibility of being truthful to a patient with delivering information in a compassionate manner, especially when the prognosis is severe?

How did you find this exercise?

Want to get ahead of Casper prep? Leave your email for the latest resources!